Early Music Recording Lists

Instrumental Music

The subject of this list is music for instrumental ensembles, largely from the later 1500s and early 1600s, and also some solo music. Although the list will have a bias both toward the viol and toward England, other instruments and outputs will be included so as to summarize my favorite examples of instrumental writing for this era, an era which might be characterized as Late Renaissance or in some cases Early Baroque.

When it comes to the abstract & austere music which I favor, the English output is rather uncharacteristically larger than that on the Continent. While many explanations might be offered for this phenomenon, including the tangible one that the Spanish & Italian output has been less thoroughly surveyed, it is true nonetheless. In each case, after the period covered by this list and sometimes during it, the instrumental styles became lighter and more sonorous. It is the abstract polyphonic gravity which I am attempting to survey here.

I will list recordings roughly chronologically. The performances of this music are generally excellent, making a welcome change from some other repertories. Many pieces have more than one recording which would otherwise merit inclusion, but I will generally confine myself to single listings. I am increasingly picky in the latter sections.

Finally, I should note that in November 2012, I folded what had previously been a separate keyboard listing into this list. This was warranted both by a shrinking list of solo keyboard recordings that I wanted to recommend relative to ensemble recordings, and a basic questioning of why I had made the distinction in the first place. So now, one instrumental list.


England

The English output can be quite compelling, even if it was mostly written over only a few decades by a handful of composers. It continues to be a personal favorite. The Renaissance fades very smoothly into the Baroque here, although there is some break as the consort medium is displaced by the Italian ensemble constitutions (the last item) and then especially with the Civil War. The repertory is now rather well-covered on CD, although performance technique does continue to improve.

Tye: Lawdes Deo (*)
Complete Consort Musicke
Hespèrion XX - Jordi Savall
Astrée 8708
Byrd: Complete Consort Music (***)
Phantasm - Laurence Dreyfus
Linn Records 372
Byrd: The Complete Keyboard Music (****)
Davitt Moroney
Hyperion 66551/7 (7 CDs)
Gibbons: Music for Viols (**)
Concordia - Mark Levy
v. 1 - Metronome 1033
v. 2 - Metronome 1039
Gibbons: Music for Harpsichord & Virginals (***)
James Johnstone
AS&V "Gaudeamus" 191
Ward: Consort Music for five and six viols (*)
Phantasm - Laurence Dreyfus
Linn Records 339
Jenkins: Five- & Six-Part Consorts (***)
Phantasm - Laurence Dreyfus
5: Avie Records 2120
6: Avie Records 2099
Jenkins: Consort Music of Four Parts (***)
The Spirit of Gambo
1: Musica Ficta 8011
2: Musica Ficta 8019
Lawes: Consorts to the organ (***)
Phantasm - Laurence Dreyfus
Linn Records 399
Lawes: Fantasia-Suites for two violins, bass viol & organ (*)
London Baroque
Harmonia Mundi 901423

Italy

There were highly varied instrumental idioms in Italy throughout the later 16th century, and especially into the 17th. The second through fourth citations represent important points of transition from the Italian Renaissance idiom. Although they tend to be rather brighter in tone than the English consort repertory, they have many interesting characteristics. There has been a renewed interest in recording the early 17th century of late, and so there is a growing discography of quality interpretations. Likewise, although I have included little of it, there is a large amount of solo keyboard (and lute) music from this period on record. The resulting variety inherent to this entire sub-listing is especially notable.

Willaert: Complete Works, Volume 7 (**)
Willaert and his circle
Ricercari da Musica Nova (1540)
Lorenzini / Negri / Villani / Azzarelli
Stradivarius 33355
Ruffo: Capricci a tre voci (*)
Accademia Strumentale Italiana - Alberto Rasi
Stradivarius Dulcimer 33337
Gabrieli: Sonate e Canzoni (*)
Per concertar con l'organo
Concerto Palatino - Bruce Dickey & Charles Toet
Harmonia Mundi 901688
Frescobaldi: Il Primo Libro delle Canzoni (**)
Il Viaggio Musicale
v. 1 - Bongiovanni 5533
v. 2 - Bongiovanni 5548
Marini: Affetti musicali (**)
Il Viaggio Musicale
Chandos Chaconne 0660
Marini: Curiose invenzioni dall'opera ottava (*)
Monica Huggett / Galatea - Paul Beier
Stradivarius 33549

Spain

In the early days of instrumental music, Spain was a leader in development, particularly in the person of Antonio de Cabezón, but then became very conservative. This section is particularly iconic, if brief.

Cabezón: Complete Tientos and Variations (***)
Glen Wilson
Naxos 8.572475-76 (2 CDs)
Antonio de Cabezón: Glosados, Diferencias, Tientos (***)
Trio Unda Maris
La mà de guido 2014
Ortiz: Recercadas del Trattado de Glosas (**)
Jordi Savall, et al.
Astrée 8717

Aside from substantial duplication, if a recording fitting the orientation of this sketch is not listed here, either I haven't been able to obtain a copy (perhaps out of print), I don't know about it at all, or I didn't care for it enough to give it one star. In the final section, obviously I am much more restrictive. Please feel free to inquire, especially if you know a recording I probably don't.

I will try to keep this page up to date as new releases appear.

To recommendation lists.

Todd M. McComb
Updated: 10 November 2014